This year’s NFL trade deadline has turned out to be incredibly active and filled with big names, highlighted by the Jets making the first truly shocking deadline transaction in years. They sent Sauce Gardner to the Colts for a pair of first-round picks. Shortly thereafter, the Cowboys got in on the action with another trade featuring New York.
MORE: NFL Trade Deadline Tracker
In the second blockbuster transaction of the day, the Jets agreed to send All-Pro defensive tackle Quinnen Williams to Dallas in exchange for a second-round pick in 2026, a first-round pick in 2027, and DT Mazi Smith. It is a huge decision by both teams and a big surprise no matter which way you slice it. Williams is only 27 years old with three Pro Bowl and one All-Pro team selections. He has six sacks this season. While his play hasn’t been terribly consistent the last two seasons the talent is obviously there, enough so that it was assumed Williams was a cornerstone of the Jets moving forward no matter how much losing was done.
Apparently not. The franchise decided the cost the Cowboys were willing to pay for his services were worth a trade. And it is a high cost indeed. Dallas is offering up the better of its two first-rounders in 2027—the Cowboys’ pick and the Packers’ pick, acquired in the Micah Parsons trade. That plus a second-rounder this year is a big bet on Williams’s potential. Not to mention his ability to fix what has been an absolutely putrid run defense, the biggest single reason for the team’s 3-5-1 start to the year.
Jerry Jones swung for the fences. Nobody can deny that. But there were many reactions on every part of the spectrum to the Cowboys’ massive trade.
Analysts react
The various personalities that dot the NFL media landscape were skeptical that Williams will solve all the Cowboys’ woes, as well as whether he’ll be worth the price they paid. But some were willing to give credit for at least trying something
The Cowboys pass rush was already decent. Adding Quinnen helps even more, and also shores up the run up front.
— Mina Kimes (@minakimes) November 4, 2025
The problem remains....everything behind the DL. 😬
Cowboys trading what might be a top-ten pick for a (great imo) defensive tackle who turns 28 this year is definitely a choice!
— Bill Barnwell (@billbarnwell) November 4, 2025
Cowboys trading a bunch of draft picks for the chance to finish 6-10-1.
— Tom Fornelli (@TomFornelli) November 4, 2025
The Cowboys are a hilarious franchise
— Matt Verderame (@MattVerderame) November 4, 2025
Now, a first and a second for Quinnen Williams? That's an overpay. https://t.co/NROI7FuItZ
— Benjamin Solak (@BenjaminSolak) November 4, 2025
I formally apologize to Jerry Jones. You promised, and you delivered old fella. Keep cooking.
— Benjamin Solak (@BenjaminSolak) November 4, 2025
So let’s recap:
— Joseph Hoyt (@JoeJHoyt) November 4, 2025
Cowboys trade: Micah Parsons, Mazi Smith, a 2026 second round pick, the better of their two 2027 first round picks
Cowboys receive: Quinnen Williams, Kenny Clark, a 2026 first round pick.
Cowboys would also say, I imagine, they received $ flexibility. https://t.co/a2dpJc0q6X
Also surprised that the Jets didn’t see Williams as a foundational piece but this looks to be a reset reset
— Ted Nguyen (@FB_FilmAnalysis) November 4, 2025
You can and should hate how the Cowboys handled the Parsons stuff, AND still be able to see this as a good deal, which I do. Williams is a very good player who should help Dallas a ton. I would have kept him if I’m the Jets, but they did get good value for him at least https://t.co/xcAFESa7ts
— Jon Ledyard (@LedyardNFLDraft) November 4, 2025
Fans react
As always, fans were ready with many jokes after the Cowboys made a big move. Dallas fans in particular seemed thrilled, though, that Jones was swinging for the fences.
Jerry Jones wasn't lying when he said "just wait what he have planned for tomorrow" 😭
— 0️⃣ (@ringthejays) November 4, 2025
Am I dreaming or is Jerry Jones actually doing stuff?
— DakMuse (@DakMuse4) November 4, 2025
Jerry Jones retool of the defense pic.twitter.com/wZEtzDt1kn
— Ryan Linkletter (@blitzlink_) November 4, 2025
Yeah, surely one DT and the worst Lb in football will fix Dallas terrible defense
— 🦅Coop〽️ (@QuinyonClamps) November 4, 2025
Jerry Jones to everyone criticizing him lately 😂😂😂 pic.twitter.com/RN9mAvw33A
— Kimberley A. Martin (@ByKimberleyA) November 4, 2025
Trading your own 1st round pick when you’re 3-5-1. I love Jerry Jones pic.twitter.com/xDvO7WHZSF
— Laz🇱🇷🦅 (@Lazerus) November 4, 2025
Jerry Jones I will never slander your name again
— DivaD4k (@D4DDYD4K) November 4, 2025
BIG W IS A COWBOY pic.twitter.com/cCWXK6SvMz
Jets players react
The fire sale in New York was shocking and left a few of Williams’s teammates reeling.
DE Jermaine Johnson responded to the news of his teammate’s trade with a truly depressing gif. You can feel the sadness coming off the screen.
https://t.co/ctwDG09TIt pic.twitter.com/88kwD1VcAs
— Jermaine Johnson II (@ii_jermaine) November 4, 2025
RB Breece Hall’s reaction had similar energy. Nothing quite hits like a simple sad face emoji.
…
— Breece Hall (@BreeceH) November 4, 2025
Both players seem not just likely but probable to follow Williams on his way out of town in some capacity. The Jets are trading anybody and everybody; they may not be done before the 4 p.m. deadline.
The Cowboys probably are, though. The Williams trade makes for the second deal Jones struck to shore up the defense, and Williams required a significant investment of assets. It would be a shock to see Dallas make another trade.
But today is showing that nobody has any idea what’s going to happen. What a deadline.
More NFL on Sports Illustrated
This article was originally published on www.si.com as NFL World Reacts to Cowboys’ Massive Trade for All-Pro DT Ahead of Deadline.